Localised irradiance distribution found in dental light curing units

Pierre Luc Michaud, Richard B.T. Price, Daniel Labrie, Frederick Rueggeberg, Braden Sullivan

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

45 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Objective To measure the localised irradiance and wavelength distributions from dental light curing units (LCUs) and establish a method to characterise their output. Methods Using a laboratory grade integrating sphere spectrometer system (Labsphere and Ocean Optics) the power, irradiance, and spectral emission were measured at the light tips of four LCUs: one plasma-arc (PAC) unit, one single peak blue light-emitting diode (blue-LED) unit, and two polywave LED (poly-LED) units. A beam profiler camera (Ophir Spiricon) was used to record the localised irradiance across the face of the light tips. The irradiance-calibrated beam profile images were then divided into 45 squares, each 1 mm2. Each square contained the irradiance information received from approximately 3200 pixels. The mean irradiance value within each square was calculated, and the distribution of irradiance values among these 45 squares across the tip-ends was examined. Additionally, the spectral emission was recorded at various regions across each light tip using the integrating sphere with a 4-mm diameter entrance aperture. Results The localised irradiance distribution was inhomogeneous in all four lights. The irradiance distribution was most uniformly distributed across the PAC tip. Both the irradiance and spectral emission from the poly-LED units were very unevenly distributed. Conclusions Reporting a single irradiance value or a single spectral range to describe the output from a curing light is both imprecise and inappropriate. Instead, an image of both the irradiance distribution and the distribution of the spectral emission across the light tip should be provided. Clinical significance The localised beam irradiance profile at the tip of dental LCUs is not uniform. Poly-LED units may deliver spectrally inhomogeneous irradiance profiles. Depending on the photoinitiator used in the RBC and the orientation of the LCU over the tooth, this non-uniformity may cause inadequate and inhomogeneous resin polymerisation, leading to poor physical properties, and premature failure of the restoration.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)129-139
Number of pages11
JournalJournal of Dentistry
Volume42
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Feb 1 2014

Fingerprint

Dental Curing Lights
Light
Oceans and Seas
Polymerization

Keywords

  • Beam uniformity
  • Irradiance beam profile
  • Light curing units
  • Localised spectral emission
  • Resin photopolymerisation

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Dentistry(all)

Cite this

Localised irradiance distribution found in dental light curing units. / Michaud, Pierre Luc; Price, Richard B.T.; Labrie, Daniel; Rueggeberg, Frederick; Sullivan, Braden.

In: Journal of Dentistry, Vol. 42, No. 2, 01.02.2014, p. 129-139.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Michaud, Pierre Luc ; Price, Richard B.T. ; Labrie, Daniel ; Rueggeberg, Frederick ; Sullivan, Braden. / Localised irradiance distribution found in dental light curing units. In: Journal of Dentistry. 2014 ; Vol. 42, No. 2. pp. 129-139.
@article{02bdf4ca846b4577a2d358c14eae7c14,
title = "Localised irradiance distribution found in dental light curing units",
abstract = "Objective To measure the localised irradiance and wavelength distributions from dental light curing units (LCUs) and establish a method to characterise their output. Methods Using a laboratory grade integrating sphere spectrometer system (Labsphere and Ocean Optics) the power, irradiance, and spectral emission were measured at the light tips of four LCUs: one plasma-arc (PAC) unit, one single peak blue light-emitting diode (blue-LED) unit, and two polywave LED (poly-LED) units. A beam profiler camera (Ophir Spiricon) was used to record the localised irradiance across the face of the light tips. The irradiance-calibrated beam profile images were then divided into 45 squares, each 1 mm2. Each square contained the irradiance information received from approximately 3200 pixels. The mean irradiance value within each square was calculated, and the distribution of irradiance values among these 45 squares across the tip-ends was examined. Additionally, the spectral emission was recorded at various regions across each light tip using the integrating sphere with a 4-mm diameter entrance aperture. Results The localised irradiance distribution was inhomogeneous in all four lights. The irradiance distribution was most uniformly distributed across the PAC tip. Both the irradiance and spectral emission from the poly-LED units were very unevenly distributed. Conclusions Reporting a single irradiance value or a single spectral range to describe the output from a curing light is both imprecise and inappropriate. Instead, an image of both the irradiance distribution and the distribution of the spectral emission across the light tip should be provided. Clinical significance The localised beam irradiance profile at the tip of dental LCUs is not uniform. Poly-LED units may deliver spectrally inhomogeneous irradiance profiles. Depending on the photoinitiator used in the RBC and the orientation of the LCU over the tooth, this non-uniformity may cause inadequate and inhomogeneous resin polymerisation, leading to poor physical properties, and premature failure of the restoration.",
keywords = "Beam uniformity, Irradiance beam profile, Light curing units, Localised spectral emission, Resin photopolymerisation",
author = "Michaud, {Pierre Luc} and Price, {Richard B.T.} and Daniel Labrie and Frederick Rueggeberg and Braden Sullivan",
year = "2014",
month = "2",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.jdent.2013.11.014",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "42",
pages = "129--139",
journal = "Journal of Dentistry",
issn = "0300-5712",
publisher = "Elsevier BV",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Localised irradiance distribution found in dental light curing units

AU - Michaud, Pierre Luc

AU - Price, Richard B.T.

AU - Labrie, Daniel

AU - Rueggeberg, Frederick

AU - Sullivan, Braden

PY - 2014/2/1

Y1 - 2014/2/1

N2 - Objective To measure the localised irradiance and wavelength distributions from dental light curing units (LCUs) and establish a method to characterise their output. Methods Using a laboratory grade integrating sphere spectrometer system (Labsphere and Ocean Optics) the power, irradiance, and spectral emission were measured at the light tips of four LCUs: one plasma-arc (PAC) unit, one single peak blue light-emitting diode (blue-LED) unit, and two polywave LED (poly-LED) units. A beam profiler camera (Ophir Spiricon) was used to record the localised irradiance across the face of the light tips. The irradiance-calibrated beam profile images were then divided into 45 squares, each 1 mm2. Each square contained the irradiance information received from approximately 3200 pixels. The mean irradiance value within each square was calculated, and the distribution of irradiance values among these 45 squares across the tip-ends was examined. Additionally, the spectral emission was recorded at various regions across each light tip using the integrating sphere with a 4-mm diameter entrance aperture. Results The localised irradiance distribution was inhomogeneous in all four lights. The irradiance distribution was most uniformly distributed across the PAC tip. Both the irradiance and spectral emission from the poly-LED units were very unevenly distributed. Conclusions Reporting a single irradiance value or a single spectral range to describe the output from a curing light is both imprecise and inappropriate. Instead, an image of both the irradiance distribution and the distribution of the spectral emission across the light tip should be provided. Clinical significance The localised beam irradiance profile at the tip of dental LCUs is not uniform. Poly-LED units may deliver spectrally inhomogeneous irradiance profiles. Depending on the photoinitiator used in the RBC and the orientation of the LCU over the tooth, this non-uniformity may cause inadequate and inhomogeneous resin polymerisation, leading to poor physical properties, and premature failure of the restoration.

AB - Objective To measure the localised irradiance and wavelength distributions from dental light curing units (LCUs) and establish a method to characterise their output. Methods Using a laboratory grade integrating sphere spectrometer system (Labsphere and Ocean Optics) the power, irradiance, and spectral emission were measured at the light tips of four LCUs: one plasma-arc (PAC) unit, one single peak blue light-emitting diode (blue-LED) unit, and two polywave LED (poly-LED) units. A beam profiler camera (Ophir Spiricon) was used to record the localised irradiance across the face of the light tips. The irradiance-calibrated beam profile images were then divided into 45 squares, each 1 mm2. Each square contained the irradiance information received from approximately 3200 pixels. The mean irradiance value within each square was calculated, and the distribution of irradiance values among these 45 squares across the tip-ends was examined. Additionally, the spectral emission was recorded at various regions across each light tip using the integrating sphere with a 4-mm diameter entrance aperture. Results The localised irradiance distribution was inhomogeneous in all four lights. The irradiance distribution was most uniformly distributed across the PAC tip. Both the irradiance and spectral emission from the poly-LED units were very unevenly distributed. Conclusions Reporting a single irradiance value or a single spectral range to describe the output from a curing light is both imprecise and inappropriate. Instead, an image of both the irradiance distribution and the distribution of the spectral emission across the light tip should be provided. Clinical significance The localised beam irradiance profile at the tip of dental LCUs is not uniform. Poly-LED units may deliver spectrally inhomogeneous irradiance profiles. Depending on the photoinitiator used in the RBC and the orientation of the LCU over the tooth, this non-uniformity may cause inadequate and inhomogeneous resin polymerisation, leading to poor physical properties, and premature failure of the restoration.

KW - Beam uniformity

KW - Irradiance beam profile

KW - Light curing units

KW - Localised spectral emission

KW - Resin photopolymerisation

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84892366189&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84892366189&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.jdent.2013.11.014

DO - 10.1016/j.jdent.2013.11.014

M3 - Article

VL - 42

SP - 129

EP - 139

JO - Journal of Dentistry

JF - Journal of Dentistry

SN - 0300-5712

IS - 2

ER -