Simulator Adaptation Syndrome (SAS) and the vestibular system

An exploratory study

A. Akinwuntan, Kwong Yew Raymond Chong, G. Daniel, J. Fleming, K. Lokey

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Driving simulators are increasingly being used for the evaluation and rehabilitation of fitness-to-drive. However, difficulties with Simulator Adaptation Syndrome (SAS) are commonly reported in the literature. In this study, we investigated the relationship between SAS and incongruences between vestibular and visual inputs. Fifteen individuals (age = 61±13 years, 9 females) who developed SAS (SAS+) and 10 individuals (age = 58±13 years, 4 females) who did not develop SAS (SAS-) during two recently completed simulatorbased driving studies participated in this study. Participants were each administered the six conditions of the Sensory Organization Test (SOT), made to rest for 30 minutes, and then drove four Wii®-based programs. Performance on the six SOT conditions and on the four the Wii®-based driving programs by SAS+ participants were compared to those of the SAS- participants. No participant reported feeling sick during the SOT. Participants in the SAS+ group performed better (p = 0.0053) than those in the SAS- group only on the SOT fifth condition, which required reliance on vestibular input for maintaining balance control. Four participants in the SAS+ versus one in the SAS- group experienced SAS during the Wii®-based driving (chisquare = 4.63, p =.0314). The results of the study suggest that individuals who developed SAS in the driving simulator probably relied more heavily on their vestibular system than individuals who did not develop SAS, and thus performed better when in situations that required significant integration of vestibular input for maintenance of equilibrium. The independent effect of the driving simulator versus the Wii driving game also suggests that specific characteristics of simulator environment immersion also likely played a role in eliciting SAS. Individuals who rely heavily on their vestibular system for balance control may be more prone to developing SAS in virtual environments that provide only minimal vestibular feedback. More studies are needed to better understand SAS and develop more effective strategies to mitigate it.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)29-38
Number of pages10
JournalAdvances in Transportation Studies
Volume2
Issue numberSPECIAL ISSUE
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 2014

Fingerprint

Simulators
organization
Group
fitness
rehabilitation
Patient rehabilitation
Virtual reality

Keywords

  • Driving
  • Posture
  • Sensory systems
  • Simulation

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Civil and Structural Engineering
  • Automotive Engineering
  • Safety, Risk, Reliability and Quality
  • Transportation

Cite this

Simulator Adaptation Syndrome (SAS) and the vestibular system : An exploratory study. / Akinwuntan, A.; Chong, Kwong Yew Raymond; Daniel, G.; Fleming, J.; Lokey, K.

In: Advances in Transportation Studies, Vol. 2, No. SPECIAL ISSUE, 01.01.2014, p. 29-38.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Akinwuntan, A. ; Chong, Kwong Yew Raymond ; Daniel, G. ; Fleming, J. ; Lokey, K. / Simulator Adaptation Syndrome (SAS) and the vestibular system : An exploratory study. In: Advances in Transportation Studies. 2014 ; Vol. 2, No. SPECIAL ISSUE. pp. 29-38.
@article{bdd2f772b80a4d8a978dac5b91d61f24,
title = "Simulator Adaptation Syndrome (SAS) and the vestibular system: An exploratory study",
abstract = "Driving simulators are increasingly being used for the evaluation and rehabilitation of fitness-to-drive. However, difficulties with Simulator Adaptation Syndrome (SAS) are commonly reported in the literature. In this study, we investigated the relationship between SAS and incongruences between vestibular and visual inputs. Fifteen individuals (age = 61±13 years, 9 females) who developed SAS (SAS+) and 10 individuals (age = 58±13 years, 4 females) who did not develop SAS (SAS-) during two recently completed simulatorbased driving studies participated in this study. Participants were each administered the six conditions of the Sensory Organization Test (SOT), made to rest for 30 minutes, and then drove four Wii{\circledR}-based programs. Performance on the six SOT conditions and on the four the Wii{\circledR}-based driving programs by SAS+ participants were compared to those of the SAS- participants. No participant reported feeling sick during the SOT. Participants in the SAS+ group performed better (p = 0.0053) than those in the SAS- group only on the SOT fifth condition, which required reliance on vestibular input for maintaining balance control. Four participants in the SAS+ versus one in the SAS- group experienced SAS during the Wii{\circledR}-based driving (chisquare = 4.63, p =.0314). The results of the study suggest that individuals who developed SAS in the driving simulator probably relied more heavily on their vestibular system than individuals who did not develop SAS, and thus performed better when in situations that required significant integration of vestibular input for maintenance of equilibrium. The independent effect of the driving simulator versus the Wii driving game also suggests that specific characteristics of simulator environment immersion also likely played a role in eliciting SAS. Individuals who rely heavily on their vestibular system for balance control may be more prone to developing SAS in virtual environments that provide only minimal vestibular feedback. More studies are needed to better understand SAS and develop more effective strategies to mitigate it.",
keywords = "Driving, Posture, Sensory systems, Simulation",
author = "A. Akinwuntan and Chong, {Kwong Yew Raymond} and G. Daniel and J. Fleming and K. Lokey",
year = "2014",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.4399/97888548735374",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "2",
pages = "29--38",
journal = "Advances in Transportation Studies",
issn = "1824-5463",
publisher = "Aracne Editrice",
number = "SPECIAL ISSUE",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Simulator Adaptation Syndrome (SAS) and the vestibular system

T2 - An exploratory study

AU - Akinwuntan, A.

AU - Chong, Kwong Yew Raymond

AU - Daniel, G.

AU - Fleming, J.

AU - Lokey, K.

PY - 2014/1/1

Y1 - 2014/1/1

N2 - Driving simulators are increasingly being used for the evaluation and rehabilitation of fitness-to-drive. However, difficulties with Simulator Adaptation Syndrome (SAS) are commonly reported in the literature. In this study, we investigated the relationship between SAS and incongruences between vestibular and visual inputs. Fifteen individuals (age = 61±13 years, 9 females) who developed SAS (SAS+) and 10 individuals (age = 58±13 years, 4 females) who did not develop SAS (SAS-) during two recently completed simulatorbased driving studies participated in this study. Participants were each administered the six conditions of the Sensory Organization Test (SOT), made to rest for 30 minutes, and then drove four Wii®-based programs. Performance on the six SOT conditions and on the four the Wii®-based driving programs by SAS+ participants were compared to those of the SAS- participants. No participant reported feeling sick during the SOT. Participants in the SAS+ group performed better (p = 0.0053) than those in the SAS- group only on the SOT fifth condition, which required reliance on vestibular input for maintaining balance control. Four participants in the SAS+ versus one in the SAS- group experienced SAS during the Wii®-based driving (chisquare = 4.63, p =.0314). The results of the study suggest that individuals who developed SAS in the driving simulator probably relied more heavily on their vestibular system than individuals who did not develop SAS, and thus performed better when in situations that required significant integration of vestibular input for maintenance of equilibrium. The independent effect of the driving simulator versus the Wii driving game also suggests that specific characteristics of simulator environment immersion also likely played a role in eliciting SAS. Individuals who rely heavily on their vestibular system for balance control may be more prone to developing SAS in virtual environments that provide only minimal vestibular feedback. More studies are needed to better understand SAS and develop more effective strategies to mitigate it.

AB - Driving simulators are increasingly being used for the evaluation and rehabilitation of fitness-to-drive. However, difficulties with Simulator Adaptation Syndrome (SAS) are commonly reported in the literature. In this study, we investigated the relationship between SAS and incongruences between vestibular and visual inputs. Fifteen individuals (age = 61±13 years, 9 females) who developed SAS (SAS+) and 10 individuals (age = 58±13 years, 4 females) who did not develop SAS (SAS-) during two recently completed simulatorbased driving studies participated in this study. Participants were each administered the six conditions of the Sensory Organization Test (SOT), made to rest for 30 minutes, and then drove four Wii®-based programs. Performance on the six SOT conditions and on the four the Wii®-based driving programs by SAS+ participants were compared to those of the SAS- participants. No participant reported feeling sick during the SOT. Participants in the SAS+ group performed better (p = 0.0053) than those in the SAS- group only on the SOT fifth condition, which required reliance on vestibular input for maintaining balance control. Four participants in the SAS+ versus one in the SAS- group experienced SAS during the Wii®-based driving (chisquare = 4.63, p =.0314). The results of the study suggest that individuals who developed SAS in the driving simulator probably relied more heavily on their vestibular system than individuals who did not develop SAS, and thus performed better when in situations that required significant integration of vestibular input for maintenance of equilibrium. The independent effect of the driving simulator versus the Wii driving game also suggests that specific characteristics of simulator environment immersion also likely played a role in eliciting SAS. Individuals who rely heavily on their vestibular system for balance control may be more prone to developing SAS in virtual environments that provide only minimal vestibular feedback. More studies are needed to better understand SAS and develop more effective strategies to mitigate it.

KW - Driving

KW - Posture

KW - Sensory systems

KW - Simulation

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84904394119&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84904394119&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.4399/97888548735374

DO - 10.4399/97888548735374

M3 - Article

VL - 2

SP - 29

EP - 38

JO - Advances in Transportation Studies

JF - Advances in Transportation Studies

SN - 1824-5463

IS - SPECIAL ISSUE

ER -