Theory of intelligent collectives

An experimental physiological approach to group decision-making

Megan McKoy, S. Spitler, Kelsey Zuchegno, E. Taylor, K. C. Hewitt, John Shallcross, Preston Roman, Nadya Clontz, Austin Goetz, Kevin Asmann, Alana Enslein, Steve H Hobbs, Robert Reeves, Tadd B Patton, W. FLawless

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Abstract

We review our theory of robust intelligence (RI) for groups. We examine the quality of decisions by groups in the laboratory under either majority rule (MR) or consensus rule (CR). Theoretically, engagement in decision-making becomes a factor depending on whether an individual is in a group or in competition between groups. From earlier research, measures of engagement in three-person groups included selfreports, counts of utterances during discussions, and changes in electro-dermal activity (i.e., galvanic skin responses, or GSR). We predicted engagement (number of utterances) would be greater under CR than MR; under MR, we predicted that GSRs would be greater (more attention). Based on partial analyses, participants under CR spoke significantly more often during discussions than MR. As predicted, after de-trending GSR data, we found MR produced higher GSRs and shorter discussions. Our recent work in group size has increased to five participants working on Wason Selection Tasks.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Title of host publicationImproving Organizational Effectiveness with Enterprise Information Systems
PublisherIGI Global
Pages188-204
Number of pages17
ISBN (Electronic)9781466683693
ISBN (Print)1466683686, 9781466683686
DOIs
StatePublished - Jul 7 2015

Fingerprint

Group decision making
Majority rule
Self-report
Factors
Group size
Detrending
Decision making

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Economics, Econometrics and Finance(all)
  • Business, Management and Accounting(all)

Cite this

McKoy, M., Spitler, S., Zuchegno, K., Taylor, E., Hewitt, K. C., Shallcross, J., ... FLawless, W. (2015). Theory of intelligent collectives: An experimental physiological approach to group decision-making. In Improving Organizational Effectiveness with Enterprise Information Systems (pp. 188-204). IGI Global. https://doi.org/10.4018/978-1-4666-8368-6.Ch012

Theory of intelligent collectives : An experimental physiological approach to group decision-making. / McKoy, Megan; Spitler, S.; Zuchegno, Kelsey; Taylor, E.; Hewitt, K. C.; Shallcross, John; Roman, Preston; Clontz, Nadya; Goetz, Austin; Asmann, Kevin; Enslein, Alana; Hobbs, Steve H; Reeves, Robert; Patton, Tadd B; FLawless, W.

Improving Organizational Effectiveness with Enterprise Information Systems. IGI Global, 2015. p. 188-204.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

McKoy, M, Spitler, S, Zuchegno, K, Taylor, E, Hewitt, KC, Shallcross, J, Roman, P, Clontz, N, Goetz, A, Asmann, K, Enslein, A, Hobbs, SH, Reeves, R, Patton, TB & FLawless, W 2015, Theory of intelligent collectives: An experimental physiological approach to group decision-making. in Improving Organizational Effectiveness with Enterprise Information Systems. IGI Global, pp. 188-204. https://doi.org/10.4018/978-1-4666-8368-6.Ch012
McKoy M, Spitler S, Zuchegno K, Taylor E, Hewitt KC, Shallcross J et al. Theory of intelligent collectives: An experimental physiological approach to group decision-making. In Improving Organizational Effectiveness with Enterprise Information Systems. IGI Global. 2015. p. 188-204 https://doi.org/10.4018/978-1-4666-8368-6.Ch012
McKoy, Megan ; Spitler, S. ; Zuchegno, Kelsey ; Taylor, E. ; Hewitt, K. C. ; Shallcross, John ; Roman, Preston ; Clontz, Nadya ; Goetz, Austin ; Asmann, Kevin ; Enslein, Alana ; Hobbs, Steve H ; Reeves, Robert ; Patton, Tadd B ; FLawless, W. / Theory of intelligent collectives : An experimental physiological approach to group decision-making. Improving Organizational Effectiveness with Enterprise Information Systems. IGI Global, 2015. pp. 188-204
@inbook{4fb66ab0ef6f4786a19129a670e8109e,
title = "Theory of intelligent collectives: An experimental physiological approach to group decision-making",
abstract = "We review our theory of robust intelligence (RI) for groups. We examine the quality of decisions by groups in the laboratory under either majority rule (MR) or consensus rule (CR). Theoretically, engagement in decision-making becomes a factor depending on whether an individual is in a group or in competition between groups. From earlier research, measures of engagement in three-person groups included selfreports, counts of utterances during discussions, and changes in electro-dermal activity (i.e., galvanic skin responses, or GSR). We predicted engagement (number of utterances) would be greater under CR than MR; under MR, we predicted that GSRs would be greater (more attention). Based on partial analyses, participants under CR spoke significantly more often during discussions than MR. As predicted, after de-trending GSR data, we found MR produced higher GSRs and shorter discussions. Our recent work in group size has increased to five participants working on Wason Selection Tasks.",
author = "Megan McKoy and S. Spitler and Kelsey Zuchegno and E. Taylor and Hewitt, {K. C.} and John Shallcross and Preston Roman and Nadya Clontz and Austin Goetz and Kevin Asmann and Alana Enslein and Hobbs, {Steve H} and Robert Reeves and Patton, {Tadd B} and W. FLawless",
year = "2015",
month = "7",
day = "7",
doi = "10.4018/978-1-4666-8368-6.Ch012",
language = "English (US)",
isbn = "1466683686",
pages = "188--204",
booktitle = "Improving Organizational Effectiveness with Enterprise Information Systems",
publisher = "IGI Global",

}

TY - CHAP

T1 - Theory of intelligent collectives

T2 - An experimental physiological approach to group decision-making

AU - McKoy, Megan

AU - Spitler, S.

AU - Zuchegno, Kelsey

AU - Taylor, E.

AU - Hewitt, K. C.

AU - Shallcross, John

AU - Roman, Preston

AU - Clontz, Nadya

AU - Goetz, Austin

AU - Asmann, Kevin

AU - Enslein, Alana

AU - Hobbs, Steve H

AU - Reeves, Robert

AU - Patton, Tadd B

AU - FLawless, W.

PY - 2015/7/7

Y1 - 2015/7/7

N2 - We review our theory of robust intelligence (RI) for groups. We examine the quality of decisions by groups in the laboratory under either majority rule (MR) or consensus rule (CR). Theoretically, engagement in decision-making becomes a factor depending on whether an individual is in a group or in competition between groups. From earlier research, measures of engagement in three-person groups included selfreports, counts of utterances during discussions, and changes in electro-dermal activity (i.e., galvanic skin responses, or GSR). We predicted engagement (number of utterances) would be greater under CR than MR; under MR, we predicted that GSRs would be greater (more attention). Based on partial analyses, participants under CR spoke significantly more often during discussions than MR. As predicted, after de-trending GSR data, we found MR produced higher GSRs and shorter discussions. Our recent work in group size has increased to five participants working on Wason Selection Tasks.

AB - We review our theory of robust intelligence (RI) for groups. We examine the quality of decisions by groups in the laboratory under either majority rule (MR) or consensus rule (CR). Theoretically, engagement in decision-making becomes a factor depending on whether an individual is in a group or in competition between groups. From earlier research, measures of engagement in three-person groups included selfreports, counts of utterances during discussions, and changes in electro-dermal activity (i.e., galvanic skin responses, or GSR). We predicted engagement (number of utterances) would be greater under CR than MR; under MR, we predicted that GSRs would be greater (more attention). Based on partial analyses, participants under CR spoke significantly more often during discussions than MR. As predicted, after de-trending GSR data, we found MR produced higher GSRs and shorter discussions. Our recent work in group size has increased to five participants working on Wason Selection Tasks.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84955102713&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84955102713&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.4018/978-1-4666-8368-6.Ch012

DO - 10.4018/978-1-4666-8368-6.Ch012

M3 - Chapter

SN - 1466683686

SN - 9781466683686

SP - 188

EP - 204

BT - Improving Organizational Effectiveness with Enterprise Information Systems

PB - IGI Global

ER -