Too much of a good thing? Physician practices and patient willingness for less frequent pap test screening intervals

Helen I. Meissner, Jasmin A. Tiro, K. Robin Yabroff, David A. Haggstrom, Steven Scott Coughlin

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

42 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background: Recent guidelines recommend longer Pap test intervals. However, physicians and patients may not be adopting these recommendations. Objectives: Identify (1) physician and practice characteristics associated with recommending a less frequent interval, and (2) characteristics associated with women's willingness to adhere to a 3-year interval. Research desing: We used 2 national surveys: (1) a 2006/2007 National Survey of Primary Care Physicians for physician cervical cancer screening practices (N = 1114), and (2) the 2005 Health Information Trends Survey for women's acceptance of longer Pap intervals (N = 2206). MEASURES AND METHODS: Physician recommendation regarding Pap intervals was measured using a clinical vignette involving a 35-year-old with no new sexual partners and 3 consecutive negative Pap tests; associations with independent variables were evaluated with logistic regression. In parallel models, we evaluated women's willingness to follow a 3-year Pap test interval. Results: A minority of physicians (32%) have adopted-but more than half of women are willing to adopt-3-year Pap test intervals. In adjusted models, physician factors associated with less frequent screening were: serving a higher proportion of Medicaid patients, white, non-Hispanic race, fewer years since medical school graduation, and US Preventive Services Task Force being very influential in physician clinical practice. Women were more willing to follow a 3-year interval if they were older, but less willing if they had personal or family experiences with cancer or followed an annual Pap test schedule. Conclusions: Many women are accepting of a 3-year interval for Pap tests, although most primary care physicians continue to recommend shorter intervals.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)249-259
Number of pages11
JournalMedical Care
Volume48
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - Mar 1 2010

Fingerprint

Papanicolaou Test
Physicians
Primary Care Physicians
Sexual Partners
Medicaid
Advisory Committees
Medical Schools
Early Detection of Cancer
Uterine Cervical Neoplasms
Appointments and Schedules
Logistic Models
Guidelines
Health
Research

Keywords

  • Behavior change
  • Cancer screening
  • Cervical cancer
  • Guidelines
  • Health service

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Public Health, Environmental and Occupational Health

Cite this

Too much of a good thing? Physician practices and patient willingness for less frequent pap test screening intervals. / Meissner, Helen I.; Tiro, Jasmin A.; Yabroff, K. Robin; Haggstrom, David A.; Coughlin, Steven Scott.

In: Medical Care, Vol. 48, No. 3, 01.03.2010, p. 249-259.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Meissner, Helen I. ; Tiro, Jasmin A. ; Yabroff, K. Robin ; Haggstrom, David A. ; Coughlin, Steven Scott. / Too much of a good thing? Physician practices and patient willingness for less frequent pap test screening intervals. In: Medical Care. 2010 ; Vol. 48, No. 3. pp. 249-259.
@article{a88245292b594b17aa45fe3ee6a1649c,
title = "Too much of a good thing? Physician practices and patient willingness for less frequent pap test screening intervals",
abstract = "Background: Recent guidelines recommend longer Pap test intervals. However, physicians and patients may not be adopting these recommendations. Objectives: Identify (1) physician and practice characteristics associated with recommending a less frequent interval, and (2) characteristics associated with women's willingness to adhere to a 3-year interval. Research desing: We used 2 national surveys: (1) a 2006/2007 National Survey of Primary Care Physicians for physician cervical cancer screening practices (N = 1114), and (2) the 2005 Health Information Trends Survey for women's acceptance of longer Pap intervals (N = 2206). MEASURES AND METHODS: Physician recommendation regarding Pap intervals was measured using a clinical vignette involving a 35-year-old with no new sexual partners and 3 consecutive negative Pap tests; associations with independent variables were evaluated with logistic regression. In parallel models, we evaluated women's willingness to follow a 3-year Pap test interval. Results: A minority of physicians (32{\%}) have adopted-but more than half of women are willing to adopt-3-year Pap test intervals. In adjusted models, physician factors associated with less frequent screening were: serving a higher proportion of Medicaid patients, white, non-Hispanic race, fewer years since medical school graduation, and US Preventive Services Task Force being very influential in physician clinical practice. Women were more willing to follow a 3-year interval if they were older, but less willing if they had personal or family experiences with cancer or followed an annual Pap test schedule. Conclusions: Many women are accepting of a 3-year interval for Pap tests, although most primary care physicians continue to recommend shorter intervals.",
keywords = "Behavior change, Cancer screening, Cervical cancer, Guidelines, Health service",
author = "Meissner, {Helen I.} and Tiro, {Jasmin A.} and Yabroff, {K. Robin} and Haggstrom, {David A.} and Coughlin, {Steven Scott}",
year = "2010",
month = "3",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1097/MLR.0b013e3181ca4015",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "48",
pages = "249--259",
journal = "Medical Care",
issn = "0025-7079",
publisher = "Lippincott Williams and Wilkins",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Too much of a good thing? Physician practices and patient willingness for less frequent pap test screening intervals

AU - Meissner, Helen I.

AU - Tiro, Jasmin A.

AU - Yabroff, K. Robin

AU - Haggstrom, David A.

AU - Coughlin, Steven Scott

PY - 2010/3/1

Y1 - 2010/3/1

N2 - Background: Recent guidelines recommend longer Pap test intervals. However, physicians and patients may not be adopting these recommendations. Objectives: Identify (1) physician and practice characteristics associated with recommending a less frequent interval, and (2) characteristics associated with women's willingness to adhere to a 3-year interval. Research desing: We used 2 national surveys: (1) a 2006/2007 National Survey of Primary Care Physicians for physician cervical cancer screening practices (N = 1114), and (2) the 2005 Health Information Trends Survey for women's acceptance of longer Pap intervals (N = 2206). MEASURES AND METHODS: Physician recommendation regarding Pap intervals was measured using a clinical vignette involving a 35-year-old with no new sexual partners and 3 consecutive negative Pap tests; associations with independent variables were evaluated with logistic regression. In parallel models, we evaluated women's willingness to follow a 3-year Pap test interval. Results: A minority of physicians (32%) have adopted-but more than half of women are willing to adopt-3-year Pap test intervals. In adjusted models, physician factors associated with less frequent screening were: serving a higher proportion of Medicaid patients, white, non-Hispanic race, fewer years since medical school graduation, and US Preventive Services Task Force being very influential in physician clinical practice. Women were more willing to follow a 3-year interval if they were older, but less willing if they had personal or family experiences with cancer or followed an annual Pap test schedule. Conclusions: Many women are accepting of a 3-year interval for Pap tests, although most primary care physicians continue to recommend shorter intervals.

AB - Background: Recent guidelines recommend longer Pap test intervals. However, physicians and patients may not be adopting these recommendations. Objectives: Identify (1) physician and practice characteristics associated with recommending a less frequent interval, and (2) characteristics associated with women's willingness to adhere to a 3-year interval. Research desing: We used 2 national surveys: (1) a 2006/2007 National Survey of Primary Care Physicians for physician cervical cancer screening practices (N = 1114), and (2) the 2005 Health Information Trends Survey for women's acceptance of longer Pap intervals (N = 2206). MEASURES AND METHODS: Physician recommendation regarding Pap intervals was measured using a clinical vignette involving a 35-year-old with no new sexual partners and 3 consecutive negative Pap tests; associations with independent variables were evaluated with logistic regression. In parallel models, we evaluated women's willingness to follow a 3-year Pap test interval. Results: A minority of physicians (32%) have adopted-but more than half of women are willing to adopt-3-year Pap test intervals. In adjusted models, physician factors associated with less frequent screening were: serving a higher proportion of Medicaid patients, white, non-Hispanic race, fewer years since medical school graduation, and US Preventive Services Task Force being very influential in physician clinical practice. Women were more willing to follow a 3-year interval if they were older, but less willing if they had personal or family experiences with cancer or followed an annual Pap test schedule. Conclusions: Many women are accepting of a 3-year interval for Pap tests, although most primary care physicians continue to recommend shorter intervals.

KW - Behavior change

KW - Cancer screening

KW - Cervical cancer

KW - Guidelines

KW - Health service

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=77649109636&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=77649109636&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1097/MLR.0b013e3181ca4015

DO - 10.1097/MLR.0b013e3181ca4015

M3 - Article

C2 - 20182268

AN - SCOPUS:77649109636

VL - 48

SP - 249

EP - 259

JO - Medical Care

JF - Medical Care

SN - 0025-7079

IS - 3

ER -