A comparison of HDR near source dosimetry using a treatment planning system, Monte Carlo simulation, and radiochromic film

Ahmad Ali Amoush, Marcus Luckstead, Michael Lamba, Howard Elson, William Kassing

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This study aimed to investigate the high-dose rate Iridium-192 brachytherapy, including near source dosimetry, of a catheter-based applicator from 0.5. mm to 1. cm along the transverse axis. Radiochromic film and Monte Carlo (MC) simulation were used to generate absolute dose for the catheter-based applicator. Results from radiochromic film and MC simulation were compared directly to the treatment planning system (TPS) based on the American Association of Physicists in Medicine Updated Task Group 43 (TG-43U1) dose calculation formalism. The difference between dose measured using radiochromic film along the transverse plane at 0.5. mm from the surface and the predicted dose by the TPS was 24%±13%. The dose difference between the MC simulation along the transverse plane at 0.5. mm from the surface and the predicted dose by the TPS was 22.1%±3%. For distances from 1.5. mm to 1. cm from the surface, radiochromic film and MC simulation agreed with TPS within an uncertainty of 3%. The TPS under-predicts the dose at the surface of the applicator, i.e., 0.5. mm from the catheter surface, as compared to the measured and MC simulation predicted dose. MC simulation results demonstrated that 15% of this error is due to neglecting the beta particles and discrete electrons emanating from the sources and not considered by the TPS, and 7% of the difference was due to the photon alone, potentially due to the differences in MC dose modeling, photon spectrum, scoring techniques, and effect of the presence of the catheter and the air gap. Beyond 1. mm from the surface, the TPS dose algorithm agrees with the experimental and MC data within 3%.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)160-164
Number of pages5
JournalMedical Dosimetry
Volume38
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 2013

Fingerprint

Catheters
Photons
Therapeutics
Beta Particles
Iridium
Brachytherapy
Uncertainty
Air
Medicine
Electrons

Keywords

  • HDR
  • MC simulation
  • Radiochromic film dosimetry
  • TG-43U1

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Radiological and Ultrasound Technology
  • Oncology
  • Radiology Nuclear Medicine and imaging

Cite this

A comparison of HDR near source dosimetry using a treatment planning system, Monte Carlo simulation, and radiochromic film. / Amoush, Ahmad Ali; Luckstead, Marcus; Lamba, Michael; Elson, Howard; Kassing, William.

In: Medical Dosimetry, Vol. 38, No. 2, 01.01.2013, p. 160-164.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Amoush, Ahmad Ali ; Luckstead, Marcus ; Lamba, Michael ; Elson, Howard ; Kassing, William. / A comparison of HDR near source dosimetry using a treatment planning system, Monte Carlo simulation, and radiochromic film. In: Medical Dosimetry. 2013 ; Vol. 38, No. 2. pp. 160-164.
@article{2295e5a4a34445fabbf692792af4d9a4,
title = "A comparison of HDR near source dosimetry using a treatment planning system, Monte Carlo simulation, and radiochromic film",
abstract = "This study aimed to investigate the high-dose rate Iridium-192 brachytherapy, including near source dosimetry, of a catheter-based applicator from 0.5. mm to 1. cm along the transverse axis. Radiochromic film and Monte Carlo (MC) simulation were used to generate absolute dose for the catheter-based applicator. Results from radiochromic film and MC simulation were compared directly to the treatment planning system (TPS) based on the American Association of Physicists in Medicine Updated Task Group 43 (TG-43U1) dose calculation formalism. The difference between dose measured using radiochromic film along the transverse plane at 0.5. mm from the surface and the predicted dose by the TPS was 24{\%}±13{\%}. The dose difference between the MC simulation along the transverse plane at 0.5. mm from the surface and the predicted dose by the TPS was 22.1{\%}±3{\%}. For distances from 1.5. mm to 1. cm from the surface, radiochromic film and MC simulation agreed with TPS within an uncertainty of 3{\%}. The TPS under-predicts the dose at the surface of the applicator, i.e., 0.5. mm from the catheter surface, as compared to the measured and MC simulation predicted dose. MC simulation results demonstrated that 15{\%} of this error is due to neglecting the beta particles and discrete electrons emanating from the sources and not considered by the TPS, and 7{\%} of the difference was due to the photon alone, potentially due to the differences in MC dose modeling, photon spectrum, scoring techniques, and effect of the presence of the catheter and the air gap. Beyond 1. mm from the surface, the TPS dose algorithm agrees with the experimental and MC data within 3{\%}.",
keywords = "HDR, MC simulation, Radiochromic film dosimetry, TG-43U1",
author = "Amoush, {Ahmad Ali} and Marcus Luckstead and Michael Lamba and Howard Elson and William Kassing",
year = "2013",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.meddos.2012.10.006",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "38",
pages = "160--164",
journal = "Medical Dosimetry",
issn = "0958-3947",
publisher = "Elsevier Inc.",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A comparison of HDR near source dosimetry using a treatment planning system, Monte Carlo simulation, and radiochromic film

AU - Amoush, Ahmad Ali

AU - Luckstead, Marcus

AU - Lamba, Michael

AU - Elson, Howard

AU - Kassing, William

PY - 2013/1/1

Y1 - 2013/1/1

N2 - This study aimed to investigate the high-dose rate Iridium-192 brachytherapy, including near source dosimetry, of a catheter-based applicator from 0.5. mm to 1. cm along the transverse axis. Radiochromic film and Monte Carlo (MC) simulation were used to generate absolute dose for the catheter-based applicator. Results from radiochromic film and MC simulation were compared directly to the treatment planning system (TPS) based on the American Association of Physicists in Medicine Updated Task Group 43 (TG-43U1) dose calculation formalism. The difference between dose measured using radiochromic film along the transverse plane at 0.5. mm from the surface and the predicted dose by the TPS was 24%±13%. The dose difference between the MC simulation along the transverse plane at 0.5. mm from the surface and the predicted dose by the TPS was 22.1%±3%. For distances from 1.5. mm to 1. cm from the surface, radiochromic film and MC simulation agreed with TPS within an uncertainty of 3%. The TPS under-predicts the dose at the surface of the applicator, i.e., 0.5. mm from the catheter surface, as compared to the measured and MC simulation predicted dose. MC simulation results demonstrated that 15% of this error is due to neglecting the beta particles and discrete electrons emanating from the sources and not considered by the TPS, and 7% of the difference was due to the photon alone, potentially due to the differences in MC dose modeling, photon spectrum, scoring techniques, and effect of the presence of the catheter and the air gap. Beyond 1. mm from the surface, the TPS dose algorithm agrees with the experimental and MC data within 3%.

AB - This study aimed to investigate the high-dose rate Iridium-192 brachytherapy, including near source dosimetry, of a catheter-based applicator from 0.5. mm to 1. cm along the transverse axis. Radiochromic film and Monte Carlo (MC) simulation were used to generate absolute dose for the catheter-based applicator. Results from radiochromic film and MC simulation were compared directly to the treatment planning system (TPS) based on the American Association of Physicists in Medicine Updated Task Group 43 (TG-43U1) dose calculation formalism. The difference between dose measured using radiochromic film along the transverse plane at 0.5. mm from the surface and the predicted dose by the TPS was 24%±13%. The dose difference between the MC simulation along the transverse plane at 0.5. mm from the surface and the predicted dose by the TPS was 22.1%±3%. For distances from 1.5. mm to 1. cm from the surface, radiochromic film and MC simulation agreed with TPS within an uncertainty of 3%. The TPS under-predicts the dose at the surface of the applicator, i.e., 0.5. mm from the catheter surface, as compared to the measured and MC simulation predicted dose. MC simulation results demonstrated that 15% of this error is due to neglecting the beta particles and discrete electrons emanating from the sources and not considered by the TPS, and 7% of the difference was due to the photon alone, potentially due to the differences in MC dose modeling, photon spectrum, scoring techniques, and effect of the presence of the catheter and the air gap. Beyond 1. mm from the surface, the TPS dose algorithm agrees with the experimental and MC data within 3%.

KW - HDR

KW - MC simulation

KW - Radiochromic film dosimetry

KW - TG-43U1

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84876980367&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84876980367&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.meddos.2012.10.006

DO - 10.1016/j.meddos.2012.10.006

M3 - Article

VL - 38

SP - 160

EP - 164

JO - Medical Dosimetry

JF - Medical Dosimetry

SN - 0958-3947

IS - 2

ER -