Addressing the Diversity-Validity Dilemma Using Situational Judgment Tests

Fern R. Juster, Robin Camhi Baum, Christopher Zou, Don Risucci, Anhphan Ly, Harold Reiter, D. Douglas Miller, Kelly L. Dore

Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

21 Scopus citations


Purpose To examine the magnitudes of score differences across different demographic groups for three academic (grade point average [GPA], old Medical College Admission Test [MCAT], and MCAT 2015) and one nonacademic (situational judgment test [SJT]) screening measures and one nonacademic (multiple miniinterview [MMI]) interview measure (analysis 1), and the demographic implications of including an SJT in the screening stage for the pool of applicants who are invited to interview (analysis 2). Method The authors ran the analyses using data from New York Medical College School of Medicine applicants from the 2015- 2016 admissions cycle. For analysis 1, effect sizes (Cohen d) were calculated for GPA, old MCAT, MCAT 2015, CASPer (an online SJT), and MMI. Comparisons were made across gender, race, ethnicity (African American, Hispanic/Latino), and socioeconomic status (SES). For analysis 2, a series of simulations were conducted to estimate the number of underrepresented in medicine (UIM) applicants who would have been invited to interview with different weightings of GPA, MCAT, and CASPer scores. Results A total of 9, 096 applicants were included in analysis 1. Group differences were significantly smaller or reversed for CASPer and MMI compared with the academic assessments (MCAT, GPA) across nearly all demographic variables/indicators. The simulations suggested that a higher weighting of CASPer may help increase gender, racial, and ethnic diversity in the interview pool; results for low-SES applicants were mixed. Conclusions The inclusion of an SJT in the admissions process has the potential to widen access to medical education for a number of UIM groups.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1197-1203
Number of pages7
JournalAcademic Medicine
Issue number8
StatePublished - 2019
Externally publishedYes

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Education


Dive into the research topics of 'Addressing the Diversity-Validity Dilemma Using Situational Judgment Tests'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this