Monte Carlo analysis of beam blocking grid design parameters

Scatter estimation and the importance of electron backscatter: Scatter

Gregory J. Bootsma, Lei Ren, Hong Zhang, JianYue Jin, David A. Jaffray

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Purpose: Beam blocking grids provide a simple and direct measurement of the scattered photon signal which degrades image quality in x-ray imaging systems, such as cone-beam CT (CBCT). This study evaluates the scatter estimation accuracy of the beam blocking method to optimize the design parameters of the grid system (e.g., grid thickness, source-To-grid distance (SGD), septa width, air interspace, and grid ratio) using Monte Carlo (MC) simulations. Method: A MC model of a CBCT imaging system with a beam blocking grid in place is made using code based on EGSnrc, with the x-ray tube portion of the simulation including electron backscatter between the anode and cathode. The inclusion of the electron backscatter allowed a more complete model of the contamination signal to be estimated. The contamination signal consists of the off-focal radiation (OFR) and source component scatter (photon scatter in source components such as tube housing, filters, and collimators). The MC model was validated against measurements collected on a bench top imaging system with a grid in place. The MC model was used to simulate 11 different grid design configurations in addition to a case with no grid. For each design a simulated projection with and without a phantom in place was computed. The simulated projections were then used to estimate the scatter and contamination portion of the signal using the signal behind the grid septa. The estimated signals from the grid data were compared to the actual signals labeled during the MC simulation. Results: Simulated results showed good agreeance with measured results with the importance of including electron backscatter resulting in off-focal radiation in the simulation being highlighted. When the source was free of contamination photons all grids performed with an error less than 8% when estimating just the scatter from the object. When the contamination photons were included in the simulation, the error in estimating both the scatter and contamination signal rose by a factor of 4 on average. In the case when both signals are present, increasing the grid thickness, changing the SGD, and reducing septa width and air interspace sizes all showed the ability to improve the grid-based estimates of the object scatter and contamination portion signal. Conclusions: The inclusion of the contamination signal in MC simulations of x-ray imaging systems is important in the design, validation, and evaluation of measurement-based scatter methods. Beam blocking grids show potential not only in object scatter estimation but in the estimation of the contamination signal, but appropriate interpolation functions must be used to account for higher frequencies found in contamination signal.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1059-1070
Number of pages12
JournalMedical Physics
Volume45
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - Mar 1 2018

Fingerprint

Photons
Electrons
X-Rays
Electrodes
Air
Radiation
Monte Carlo Method
Cone-Beam Computed Tomography

Keywords

  • Monte Carlo simulations
  • cone-beam CT
  • imaging artifacts
  • moving grid
  • off-focal radiation
  • scatter correction

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Biophysics
  • Radiology Nuclear Medicine and imaging

Cite this

Monte Carlo analysis of beam blocking grid design parameters : Scatter estimation and the importance of electron backscatter: Scatter. / Bootsma, Gregory J.; Ren, Lei; Zhang, Hong; Jin, JianYue; Jaffray, David A.

In: Medical Physics, Vol. 45, No. 3, 01.03.2018, p. 1059-1070.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Bootsma, Gregory J. ; Ren, Lei ; Zhang, Hong ; Jin, JianYue ; Jaffray, David A. / Monte Carlo analysis of beam blocking grid design parameters : Scatter estimation and the importance of electron backscatter: Scatter. In: Medical Physics. 2018 ; Vol. 45, No. 3. pp. 1059-1070.
@article{dbed96c29e7d4933b0d4b99167e6ad73,
title = "Monte Carlo analysis of beam blocking grid design parameters: Scatter estimation and the importance of electron backscatter: Scatter",
abstract = "Purpose: Beam blocking grids provide a simple and direct measurement of the scattered photon signal which degrades image quality in x-ray imaging systems, such as cone-beam CT (CBCT). This study evaluates the scatter estimation accuracy of the beam blocking method to optimize the design parameters of the grid system (e.g., grid thickness, source-To-grid distance (SGD), septa width, air interspace, and grid ratio) using Monte Carlo (MC) simulations. Method: A MC model of a CBCT imaging system with a beam blocking grid in place is made using code based on EGSnrc, with the x-ray tube portion of the simulation including electron backscatter between the anode and cathode. The inclusion of the electron backscatter allowed a more complete model of the contamination signal to be estimated. The contamination signal consists of the off-focal radiation (OFR) and source component scatter (photon scatter in source components such as tube housing, filters, and collimators). The MC model was validated against measurements collected on a bench top imaging system with a grid in place. The MC model was used to simulate 11 different grid design configurations in addition to a case with no grid. For each design a simulated projection with and without a phantom in place was computed. The simulated projections were then used to estimate the scatter and contamination portion of the signal using the signal behind the grid septa. The estimated signals from the grid data were compared to the actual signals labeled during the MC simulation. Results: Simulated results showed good agreeance with measured results with the importance of including electron backscatter resulting in off-focal radiation in the simulation being highlighted. When the source was free of contamination photons all grids performed with an error less than 8{\%} when estimating just the scatter from the object. When the contamination photons were included in the simulation, the error in estimating both the scatter and contamination signal rose by a factor of 4 on average. In the case when both signals are present, increasing the grid thickness, changing the SGD, and reducing septa width and air interspace sizes all showed the ability to improve the grid-based estimates of the object scatter and contamination portion signal. Conclusions: The inclusion of the contamination signal in MC simulations of x-ray imaging systems is important in the design, validation, and evaluation of measurement-based scatter methods. Beam blocking grids show potential not only in object scatter estimation but in the estimation of the contamination signal, but appropriate interpolation functions must be used to account for higher frequencies found in contamination signal.",
keywords = "Monte Carlo simulations, cone-beam CT, imaging artifacts, moving grid, off-focal radiation, scatter correction",
author = "Bootsma, {Gregory J.} and Lei Ren and Hong Zhang and JianYue Jin and Jaffray, {David A.}",
year = "2018",
month = "3",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1002/mp.12756",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "45",
pages = "1059--1070",
journal = "Medical Physics",
issn = "0094-2405",
publisher = "AAPM - American Association of Physicists in Medicine",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Monte Carlo analysis of beam blocking grid design parameters

T2 - Scatter estimation and the importance of electron backscatter: Scatter

AU - Bootsma, Gregory J.

AU - Ren, Lei

AU - Zhang, Hong

AU - Jin, JianYue

AU - Jaffray, David A.

PY - 2018/3/1

Y1 - 2018/3/1

N2 - Purpose: Beam blocking grids provide a simple and direct measurement of the scattered photon signal which degrades image quality in x-ray imaging systems, such as cone-beam CT (CBCT). This study evaluates the scatter estimation accuracy of the beam blocking method to optimize the design parameters of the grid system (e.g., grid thickness, source-To-grid distance (SGD), septa width, air interspace, and grid ratio) using Monte Carlo (MC) simulations. Method: A MC model of a CBCT imaging system with a beam blocking grid in place is made using code based on EGSnrc, with the x-ray tube portion of the simulation including electron backscatter between the anode and cathode. The inclusion of the electron backscatter allowed a more complete model of the contamination signal to be estimated. The contamination signal consists of the off-focal radiation (OFR) and source component scatter (photon scatter in source components such as tube housing, filters, and collimators). The MC model was validated against measurements collected on a bench top imaging system with a grid in place. The MC model was used to simulate 11 different grid design configurations in addition to a case with no grid. For each design a simulated projection with and without a phantom in place was computed. The simulated projections were then used to estimate the scatter and contamination portion of the signal using the signal behind the grid septa. The estimated signals from the grid data were compared to the actual signals labeled during the MC simulation. Results: Simulated results showed good agreeance with measured results with the importance of including electron backscatter resulting in off-focal radiation in the simulation being highlighted. When the source was free of contamination photons all grids performed with an error less than 8% when estimating just the scatter from the object. When the contamination photons were included in the simulation, the error in estimating both the scatter and contamination signal rose by a factor of 4 on average. In the case when both signals are present, increasing the grid thickness, changing the SGD, and reducing septa width and air interspace sizes all showed the ability to improve the grid-based estimates of the object scatter and contamination portion signal. Conclusions: The inclusion of the contamination signal in MC simulations of x-ray imaging systems is important in the design, validation, and evaluation of measurement-based scatter methods. Beam blocking grids show potential not only in object scatter estimation but in the estimation of the contamination signal, but appropriate interpolation functions must be used to account for higher frequencies found in contamination signal.

AB - Purpose: Beam blocking grids provide a simple and direct measurement of the scattered photon signal which degrades image quality in x-ray imaging systems, such as cone-beam CT (CBCT). This study evaluates the scatter estimation accuracy of the beam blocking method to optimize the design parameters of the grid system (e.g., grid thickness, source-To-grid distance (SGD), septa width, air interspace, and grid ratio) using Monte Carlo (MC) simulations. Method: A MC model of a CBCT imaging system with a beam blocking grid in place is made using code based on EGSnrc, with the x-ray tube portion of the simulation including electron backscatter between the anode and cathode. The inclusion of the electron backscatter allowed a more complete model of the contamination signal to be estimated. The contamination signal consists of the off-focal radiation (OFR) and source component scatter (photon scatter in source components such as tube housing, filters, and collimators). The MC model was validated against measurements collected on a bench top imaging system with a grid in place. The MC model was used to simulate 11 different grid design configurations in addition to a case with no grid. For each design a simulated projection with and without a phantom in place was computed. The simulated projections were then used to estimate the scatter and contamination portion of the signal using the signal behind the grid septa. The estimated signals from the grid data were compared to the actual signals labeled during the MC simulation. Results: Simulated results showed good agreeance with measured results with the importance of including electron backscatter resulting in off-focal radiation in the simulation being highlighted. When the source was free of contamination photons all grids performed with an error less than 8% when estimating just the scatter from the object. When the contamination photons were included in the simulation, the error in estimating both the scatter and contamination signal rose by a factor of 4 on average. In the case when both signals are present, increasing the grid thickness, changing the SGD, and reducing septa width and air interspace sizes all showed the ability to improve the grid-based estimates of the object scatter and contamination portion signal. Conclusions: The inclusion of the contamination signal in MC simulations of x-ray imaging systems is important in the design, validation, and evaluation of measurement-based scatter methods. Beam blocking grids show potential not only in object scatter estimation but in the estimation of the contamination signal, but appropriate interpolation functions must be used to account for higher frequencies found in contamination signal.

KW - Monte Carlo simulations

KW - cone-beam CT

KW - imaging artifacts

KW - moving grid

KW - off-focal radiation

KW - scatter correction

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85041722753&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85041722753&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/mp.12756

DO - 10.1002/mp.12756

M3 - Article

VL - 45

SP - 1059

EP - 1070

JO - Medical Physics

JF - Medical Physics

SN - 0094-2405

IS - 3

ER -